So I was reading a post where the writer (who is transgendered) wonders if Brienne from A Song of Ice and Fire is transgendered. For those of you not watching A Game of Thrones (where she appeared for the first time last week) or familiar with the books, she's a woman warrior who is better than many of the men she faces. She's built like a warrior. She looks like a warrior. She is not, at least as far as I got in the books, transgendered. However, there's nothing wrong with wondering and speculating about fictional characters. I think we might all do that from time to time. *winks*
However, one of the people commenting to the post said this: "I agree that she is living the only way she can. Women in Westeros who want to be soldiers or knights have to wear the clothes and walk the walk. There are several women, like the She-Bear of Mormont, who are strong female figures and not afraid to be strong. I wonder how many of them would transition if that was an option." Maybe it's me, but I find that statement appalling because of the suggestion that "strong female figures" who are "not afraid to be strong" must naturally want to be men and not strong, empowered women. I guess, if I follow the broadest assumptions in that statement, women aren't inclined to, aren't able to, or don't desire to be strong and empowered. Also, by selecting only women of a certain body type, profession, and physical features, the implication is also there that women who are more stereotypically feminine (I'm thinking here of Dany) can't be strong or unafraid of their strength.
I find both those notions more than a little unsettling.
However, one of the people commenting to the post said this: "I agree that she is living the only way she can. Women in Westeros who want to be soldiers or knights have to wear the clothes and walk the walk. There are several women, like the She-Bear of Mormont, who are strong female figures and not afraid to be strong. I wonder how many of them would transition if that was an option." Maybe it's me, but I find that statement appalling because of the suggestion that "strong female figures" who are "not afraid to be strong" must naturally want to be men and not strong, empowered women. I guess, if I follow the broadest assumptions in that statement, women aren't inclined to, aren't able to, or don't desire to be strong and empowered. Also, by selecting only women of a certain body type, profession, and physical features, the implication is also there that women who are more stereotypically feminine (I'm thinking here of Dany) can't be strong or unafraid of their strength.
I find both those notions more than a little unsettling.